Clan War type "1 vs 1"

17 replies [Last post]
RENA * BBSQUAD
Renatalis's picture
Offline
Joined: Nov 2005
Posts:
I like that idea and vote YES
45% (17 votes)
I cannot decide
8% (3 votes)
I dislike that idea and vote NO
47% (18 votes)
Total votes: 38

BBSQUAD CLAN
- All those moments will be lost in time, like tears in rain. Time to die...

mow Q [EN]
Offline
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts:
Clan War type "1 vs 1"

wanna be honest, i dont like the idea, it has nothing to do with clanpower.

for me is a clan a lil community, so, if we have to play results by 1on1, i dont c that a clan is neccary (i clearly understood ur suggestion, but thats not for what a clan is built for)

the result for clanranking would be not true, because many clans let just there 1on1-top-players play and for a normal cw, they need to take what they have.

bad point for generall ranking.

btw, isnt it a suggestion and so offtopic?

HYPER'DRAGON
Dragon.'s picture
Offline
Joined: Jun 2005
Posts:
Clan War type "1 vs 1"

sounds are nice for me , F1 .
i like 1vs1 Cool

mow Q [EN]
Offline
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts:
Clan War type "1 vs 1"

dragon, where is ur argument, why this would be good for "generell" (allgmeinens) ranking? where it does show "clanskill", clanskill be shown just in "teamgames", otherwise, for what u need a generell ranking, if wars get decided by 2 or 3 1on1s? also the 1on1 ranking is kinda for nothing than. THIS IDEA IS PRETTY GOOD for 1on1 ranking forum, but not for CLANRANKING even if there are 2-3 1on1s per match.

TEEHACE.DS
TeHaCe's picture
Offline
Joined: Nov 2005
Posts:
Clan War type "1 vs 1"

mowq vot is no couse in him clan members much play in tdm and freez, I think they haven't good players on 1v1 and I understand that but I think in others clans players like 1v1 and vote yes and my vote is YES!

Warren G
FELiX's picture
Offline
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts:
Clan War type "1 vs 1"

@mow
after long conversation me with rena, we changed one: now game from suggestion dont will rank in clan rank. I first version it will be add to rank forum. For me 1v1 tdm or 1v1 tag = duel game, i dont see any different between it so is unfair rank it as teamplay. It can be rank in different new rank in 1v1 forum.

now i dont have any arguments against.

mow Q [EN]
Offline
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts:
Clan War type "1 vs 1"

i clearly underlined that it is ok for 1on1 forum Winking, so, np for that Happy

but i also must say, it seems i havent read renas suggestion exactly, sorry for that Happy

(HK)?aSaB
bazine's picture
Offline
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts:
Clan War type "1 vs 1"

i also had same reaction than mow , this morning,cause i didnt read carefully the post. now i read it carefully , and i think it is nice idea , why not if you , rena can handle it.cause it will be lotta work.

ps : and this is off the record..rena , u need to choose a guy here , (not me , i am very bad at numbers..somebody with the will to work on it.) and show him closely how u do this clan ranking system, wich application u use etc....cause if one day u decide to go on vacation for a month in one croatian beach , we need somebody else to take over. Cool

Warren G
FELiX's picture
Offline
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts:
Clan War type "1 vs 1"

Quote:
Casablanca:
i also had same reaction than mow , this morning,cause i didnt read carefully the post. now i read it carefully , and i think it is nice idea , why not if you , rena can handle it.cause it will be lotta work.

U read old version. Old version had "match will add to clan rank". I thought this same like mow and U casa. When i was talking with drill he had this same opinion.

¯¯__█ALI█¯¯__
xpaliminium's picture
Offline
Joined: Nov 2005
Posts:
Clan War type "1 vs 1"

Laughing LOL, I have written that with only seeing : Delete please... on the other topic Big grin
pls the ones that have posted delete ur posts in the inversed order on the other topic !!

hmm, i have an amelioration if you would like to have a teamwork :

like it is done actually in CWs, the spec members tell to the ones playing where is enemy by a team speak program or such... or maybe binds
It can be done here too.

other thing is that 1vs1 of only 1 player of the clan and other one from the opponent clan is not enough :

so :
- 3 players is minimum like in CWs
- 3 maps minimum or more : a different player in each map for each team : it means that a member can play only one map per cw (and then there is strategies of choosing players and of knowing the enemy).

if the idea comes that way, I will accept it so F1 then

btw, nice initiantive rena Happy

Wanna avoid seeying mow, skull & co Surprise

Check this peacefull place

{D*R*T} BODZ!
XbODz's picture
Offline
Joined: May 2005
Posts:
Clan War type "1 vs 1"

can't see exactly the team work in 1v1, so i can't use the word clanwar too concerning a 1v1 game.

But i'm not against it, if ppl may have fun doing clanwars with 1v1 games, maybe it's a lil borring for the rest of the clan specting but why not Happy