Forum rulez o.O

31 replies [Last post]
NecrogeddoN
necrogeddon's picture
Offline
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts:
Forum rulez o.O

I don't see how postcount should even matter. From time to time I'm prone to the occasional short but to-the-point "Good game [insert clan names here]!" and a polite request for demos if available. Or remarks about one or another player's score/stats... but only when the games are of personal interest to me (e.g., I know a lot of the players, or it's a highly anticipated game -- read: DS vs SWE? hello, INSPIRING outcome there, folks).

Anyway, I'm straying from the topic a bit. I think people being worried about post count is crap. Look at Zenus and Vobb's postcount vs. join date (both joined April of '04). Look at Tass, Zyzio, Cash. Right. All under 100 posts even though they've been forum members for over a year. Or two years. Or THREE.

Play against these guys once. Once is all it'll take. When you're out of shock long enough to recover basic motor skills and then remove your jaw from the floor because of how bad you got your a$$ PWND, consider postcount and how important it really is. Winking

Expending the effort to remove postcount from the forums would be about as big of a waste of time as spending hours of time on the forums INCREASING your postcount when you could, in fact, be playing.

Which is what I'm going to go do now before I'm too tired to keep my eyes open. Winking

  • NVidia GeForce 8400GS

  • Logitech MX510

  • Hyperglide Teflon Skates

  • Steelpad QcK+

  • iHome IH-K200MB

  • SB Live! 5.1 Platinum

  • Logitech Precision Gaming Headphones

  • Insignia 32" HDTV

Arax'KG
ar4xis's picture
Offline
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts:
Forum rulez o.O
NecrogeddoN wrote:

blah blah..

Says the bish who's got 1127 posts Happy

Though I get what you mean and post-count doesn't really matter (unless you want to see what spam-rank your going to get next Winking).

pandora!box
Offline
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts:
Forum rulez o.O
NecrogeddoN wrote:

...postcount...

I think u dont get it. Ye - post count does not mark how respected in the comunity u are - its obvious for most of ppl. But for some this small number IS like a competition - they will spam, post irrevelent messages just to increase it. Result: forum is slowly changing into garbage. And ffs what for u need the number of posted messages under ur screenname? Maybe couse u r getting excited about over 1.000 number? So pls ... that would be a hipocrysy, and disabling postcount takes moreless like 3 mins to do.

[MR.]MIRCWAR
tyfon's picture
Offline
Joined: Mar 2005
Posts:
SE Sweden
Forum rulez o.O

Since this seems to have evolved into a general discussion about this forum here are my thoughts:

The number one problem (IMO) with this forum is the diffuse distinction between general forums and off topic. As it is now most posts about Quake are found in the off topic section (!) and most off topic post at the general section. We need more, and more active mods who can move subjects etc and enforce a clear distinction between the two sub-forums. As a result we will have more active and serious discussions. My belief is that it will also attract more newbies to the discussion, as it is now it's simply too messy.

Also posts in the off topic area shouldn't be post-counted.

I would also like too see a rule list for mods (how they should moderate e.g. write in locked threads and explain why it was locked etc, I understand this is a private forum and we are guests but it's just a personal opinion)

Hf

NecrogeddoN
necrogeddon's picture
Offline
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts:
Forum rulez o.O

Dudes, it's as simple as this. Remove post-count giving a "rank". :roll:

  • NVidia GeForce 8400GS

  • Logitech MX510

  • Hyperglide Teflon Skates

  • Steelpad QcK+

  • iHome IH-K200MB

  • SB Live! 5.1 Platinum

  • Logitech Precision Gaming Headphones

  • Insignia 32" HDTV

.aNk/xXxp4l/:bR.Shady'XYN!
ShadyAK's picture
Offline
Joined: Jul 2006
Posts:
GB United Kingdom
Forum rulez o.O
NecrogeddoN wrote:

Dudes, it's as simple as this. Remove post-count giving a "rank". :roll:

I remember Mad proposing to be able to give yourself a rank under the avatar (i.e. write anything you want), i wouldnt mind that...

In fact, I would love that, because of all the people saying stuff like "#1 Spammer :D" , and "hope you beat Mad @ the postcount 1 day" assuming that if i do post a lot that i give a fuck about all that "+1" stuff jus cos I whore myself out to the community...

I do think that removing the post count will stop giving people that general "+1!" impression of me...

[+]

(*WASP*SH▲DOWKNIGHT) wrote:
nonsense repellent declamatory

Arax'KG
ar4xis's picture
Offline
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts:
Forum rulez o.O
.aNk/xXxp4l/:bR.Shady'XYN! wrote:

NecrogeddoN wrote:
Dudes, it's as simple as this. Remove post-count giving a "rank". :roll:

I remember Mad proposing to be able to give yourself a rank under the avatar (i.e. write anything you want), i wouldnt mind that...

In fact, I would love that, because of all the people saying stuff like "#1 Spammer :D" , and "hope you beat Mad @ the postcount 1 day" assuming that if i do post a lot that i give a fuck about all that "+1" stuff jus cos I whore myself out to the community...

I do think that removing the post count will stop giving people that general "+1!" impression of me...

It just shows that ones with the greatest postcount don't give a sh*t about it. The people who try to catch up to them do, on the other hand.

madbringer
Madbringer's picture
Offline
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts:
Forum rulez o.O

Well, since you guys have already cleverly dragged my thread off-topic i might as well join the whole "post-count" discussion.

And i must say - i seriously can't understand why people think disabling post count altogether would help stop the spam. It would help some, true, but the real spammers here don't care about the number under their name, they just ... spam. For the sake of it. That's why it's called spam in the first place.

From my own experience "disabling" anything or "removing" anything isn't fixing shit - it never worked on any of the forum communities i've been a member of in the past. What does work, tho, is aggressive moderation and keeping heavy-duty whores and spammers under tabs.

But whatever, coz apparently i'm the number one hoe here. Laughing WTF, is this a penis lenght show-off? Post count is supposed to show one's activity, not to be used as a "Mai nummbr is b1gr thaaan j00, s o ima b3ttAr!1!". Most people with larger than average post count around here don't go around demanding respect for it, or something similiarly stupid, but either completely ignore the fact, or use it as a base for jokes (like Necro did a couple of times) Confused

What i did seen work against spammers, trolls and other trouble makers is not some semi-functional ways like the one proposed but simply - a solid base of very active moderators and administrators who set some rules and follow them. Sensible, well described rules, that is.

--

On the other hand, i could be completely and utterly wrong. Maybe spammers here DO care about the post count, and it's the only reason why they spam in the first place. If that's the case, disable it immediately. There's only so much "GG" posts a person can take Confused

KosY
Offline
Joined: May 2005
Posts:
Forum rulez o.O

2 things ive seen that seems to b the rules

DONT SPAM IDIOT!!

and that post of deex when they removed trance's avtar:P

thats all Happy

Ty foksie

Arax'KG
ar4xis's picture
Offline
Joined: Feb 2006
Posts:
Forum rulez o.O
CROW . RS* wrote:

nice game!

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG mates!!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg hyper!

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG PHC!

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG!

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG!

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG both! nice frag term on dm17!!

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG both! Laughing

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG!

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG both!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg!! nice BBS!! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg ! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG mates!

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both!

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG both!

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG mates!

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG mates!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG mates?! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG mates!

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG m8!

CROW . RS* wrote:

good PHC, nice CLASS! GG!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg mates!

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG mates!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gerat game KA!(sic)

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG both!

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG both!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both! nice !<A!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg m8!

CROW . RS* wrote:

nice game both!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both!

CROW . RS* wrote:

nice game!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg mates!

CROW . RS* wrote:

nice game both! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg sweet!
nice DEST!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg mates! nice DA!

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG mates! RS gg! nice KA!

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG BOTH!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg PHC!

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG both!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg DA nice BBS! Very Happy

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG mates! nice TC!

CROW . RS* wrote:

+1 Laughing Laughing out loud Big grin Laughing out loud

CROW . RS* wrote:

i dont accept this spammmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm ...

CROW . RS* wrote:

Big grin Laughing out loud Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

nice started! GG

CROW . RS* wrote:

Big grin Laughing out loud!

CROW . RS* wrote:

hi Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both!

CROW . RS* wrote:

GL&HF! :twisted: Evil

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both! nice game!

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG both! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

nice game both! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG both!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg! my god! Arrow dm17

CROW . RS* wrote:

2nd Big grin Laughing out loud

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG both! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both! nice on dm17!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both! nice CSA! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG both Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

nice game Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

go go MNC! gg both!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both Big grin interesting!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both! nice KO! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both! nice DEVA! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg mates! nice C4!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both! closed (sic) games! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg mates! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

+1 Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both! nice RS!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

wow dm17! nice game!

CROW . RS* wrote:

dm11 is good for TC but the others not! Big grin nice EVOL!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg DEVA! nice game DS!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG MATES! finally the cw was ranked! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg mates ! wow dm17 Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

wow close games! adrenaline! go go go! nice game both!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both! nice round! hehe Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

WoW! gg 2!S! nice SWE! quake 3 monsters! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

nice game! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both! wow dm17!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg da! nice EVOL! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both! gg MNC Big grin Thinking

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both!

CROW . RS* wrote:

+1! hehe Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

+1 Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

GG Big grin!

CROW . RS* wrote:

nice KA! gg 2sweet! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

nice TC! gg KA! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg guys?! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg guys!

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both! close!

CROW . RS* wrote:

wow 46? i am too late!

CROW . RS* wrote:

wow this is unlucky! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg 2!S! nice KO! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

:twisted: :twisted: :twisted:
:twisted: :twisted: :twisted:

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg DA! nice PHC! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

Sad

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

gg both! nice EVOL! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

wow again dm17! nice both! Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

16+1=17 Big grin but a little late hehe!

CROW . RS* wrote:

17+1+1= 19 Big grin

CROW . RS* wrote:

Big grin

I omitted each post in which he had something to say, or cw posts in which he took part or which were made after a inspiring outcome.