E+ judges

48 replies [Last post]

15. May 2006 - 9:18

#11

Offline

Joined: Sep 2003

Posts:

E+ judges

I think it is a horrible idea. It is hard enough to get two clans to be in time and get everyone together for a CW. Add a "licenced" judge to that equation.

Sorry, but CW needs to be as easy as possible to manage. If two clanleaders decide on a time/place and need to quickly set up a new time/place they should be able too.

In an official league with limited amounts of matches, fine, but not in the current "ranking" system.

BTW, the current ranking system is useless You can play 100 games and loose 95 and be ahead in ranking against a team that played 4 games and won all. All you have to do to keep the best clan last in list is not to play CW against it..

15. May 2006 - 10:02

#12

Offline

Joined: Jun 2005

Posts:

E+ judges

bo, we are already arranging a new system, system wich will need judges.

also, the goal is to have somewhat one judge per clan. that way theres almost certanly a judge available.

judges will have rank, beggining judges will be able to handle smaller fights etc, high ranked judges will be able to moderate leagues and tournaments.

so i hear you aplied bo?

I am proud of spreading a pirated Excessive Plus version and claim to be the original author, yay!

15. May 2006 - 10:17

#13

Offline

Joined: Nov 2003

Posts:

E+ judges

gotta agree with bo. 2 much of bureacracy is stinking badly. Also lets try to treat ppl seriosly - as I bet they are enough of mature to handle things by themselfes and if some misunderstanding appears it usually is being cleared up really fast.

so - imo no need to add another complications. bo explained it pretty well.

15. May 2006 - 10:33

#14

Offline

Joined: Feb 2006

Posts:

E+ judges

wrote:

I like the idea
HQ, Foksie'LoY, Nihil, Rena, Ratz, 1337w4r3z, Starless, Flex1, Bert etc.

It's a great idea. Also, I want to nominate Term, Mowly, Goddam, Casa, Seal, Drill, and Hyper*Dragon.

NVidia GeForce 8400GS
Logitech MX510
Hyperglide Teflon Skates
Steelpad QcK+
iHome IH-K200MB
SB Live! 5.1 Platinum
Logitech Precision Gaming Headphones
Insignia 32" HDTV

15. May 2006 - 10:35

#15

Offline

Joined: Sep 2003

Posts:

E+ judges

wrote:

...system wich will need judges.

Why? Show some trust in clanleaders to handle it themselves as Pan said.

wrote:

so i hear you aplied bo?

Oh *hell* no.. The idea is nice enough, to make it work practically is a completelly different matter. I just can't see any way that it would help the community or ranking system. What WOULD help is something that would simplify clanswars, not the other way around, we do want more matches and easier right?

First Euro TDM league had "judges" in the form or official admins... Atleast on paper. Lets just say it didnt work The rules as I remember said that it required an "official admin" or something like that. I dont remember a single match we had one present and that was a limited league with what? 8-10 clans?

15. May 2006 - 10:37

#16

Offline

Joined: Feb 2006

Posts:

E+ judges

(HK) Casa would make a good judge, in my opinion.

"No eternal reward will forgive us now for wasting the dawn"

15. May 2006 - 10:43

#17

Offline

Joined: Nov 2005

Posts:

E+ judges

In E+ World Cup of Nations we try to use referees, and our experiance is excelent. Teams is not obligate to call referee. But so far majority do.

IMO I am for similar in clan wars. E+ make list of referees.

1. Clans dont need to ask for them. (If they will have any truobles after match it is then they problem, and remach must be done with referee.)
2. If they wanna to, just ask for referee, and one of referees will be nominate for taht CW. Simple.

Also E+ will for beginer clans provide server for CW.

So, my proposition is: Let clans decide if they need referee or not.

Regards.

BBSQUAD CLAN
- All those moments will be lost in time, like tears in rain. Time to die...

15. May 2006 - 10:45

#18

Offline

Joined: Sep 2003

Posts:

E+ judges

wrote:

In E+ World Cup of Nations we try to use referees, and our experiance is excelent.

On the other hand, E+ WC has had kinda huge problems getting teams together for CW's correct?

but other than that, Rena's idea is good. If it is optional then it is fine. If my clan wants to fight another clan and we know it might be problems after it is good to have the *option* to call on a referee.

15. May 2006 - 10:47

#19

Offline

Joined: Nov 2005

Posts:

E+ judges

SuperBo! wrote:

wrote:
In E+ World Cup of Nations we try to use referees, and our experiance is excelent.

On the other hand, E+ WC has had kinda huge problems getting teams together for CW's correct?

but other than that, Rena's idea is good. If it is optional then it is fine. If my clan wants to fight another clan and we know it might be problems after it is good to have the *option* to call on a referee.

That was exactly my point !

We have problems in "E+ World Coup of Nations" before HQ and I take organisation, now all things going smoothly.

Regards.

BBSQUAD CLAN
- All those moments will be lost in time, like tears in rain. Time to die...

15. May 2006 - 10:52

#20

Site administrator

Offline

Joined: Feb 2004

Posts:

E+ judges

wrote:

bo, we are already arranging a new system, system wich will need judges.

also, the goal is to have somewhat one judge per clan. that way theres almost certanly a judge available.

judges will have rank, beggining judges will be able to handle smaller fights etc, high ranked judges will be able to moderate leagues and tournaments.

so i hear you aplied bo?

Rank.. So are we talking about clan leaders, admins and time done in E+ & age/ current occupation take precedence over other registrants or higher/lower ranking Judges? :roll:

[E+] Organisation is set up as old veterans of E+. Perhaps, an integration of the 2 would be of the best? We have all witnessed a many of CWs, in our time in E+.

ExcessivePlus Administrator