®HYPER 2:1 THC / ROUND 5 - 18.02.2011
wrote:wrote:wrote:What the hell is a referee for? Just to make mvd's? Ref's should know all the rules before a match and should be held responsible for disputes between teams. Fact is, ref let Deuter play so match should stand.do not meddle in their affairs, that being said he can play.. its not my problem.
wrote:
it was fair game, Deuter my br0 heheehehehehehehe could play bcos he's in the hyp and match cant be return. RegardzSticker for you, kid.
u havent sense of humor guy, go watch more monitor..
"wery"
now what we´ve got here????
not clear rule, missunderstanding between hyper and thc, misstakes by ?????
first of all i would propose to change rule to something like this.
A person becoming full member have to wait, at least 1 game is played in league until its allowed to him/her to play in league!!
second ofc we will stand up again to replay this game, if thc need this.
to call it a lie its not nice... if u see my rule suggestiom and standing rule u will c much different.
i asked deuter is it allowed to u to play, coz i read that rules in past, and cant remember, he said yes and i trusted him and not with bad ending. i cant find rule about trials for 1.5 month, i mean recruited ppl some time before this league started and we played some TDM-L games aslong he was trial.
Topic unlocked!
Topic is unlocked !
Final decision:
The leader of a team responsible not the rule be broken. The referees can not always pay attention to everything. The responsibility is still one of the teams.
If a team has broken the rules and lost, remains the result.
If a team has broken the rules and won there must be a return match.
Both teams have to plan a return within a week.
Trial members of the teams are not allowed to play, as described already in the TDM Forum.
If the person is a full member, he must wait for the next game. That is a very easy to understand rule.
It is counted the forum entry = New Clan Members
Easy to understand-true.
Wasn't clear though.
It is now, so there wont be any problems in future.
Thanks.
Bye.
Enjoy
Your
Life
Signing out....
Deu**r
I have asked Asphyx to quote our opinion about this issue, but he forgot to probably. So here it goes:
Everything went entirely wrong this time, we need to get this
straight. We had doubts if some Hyp players are eligible to play, this
is why we have asked Hypers if everything is fine regarding the rules.
We did not know if a certain player have passed trial right before the
game, or within the time before the previous TDML round. Prolly if the
player is allowed to play, or not. It was pretty messy before/during the
game (till the game was posted I was sure DM7 was our map, and DM17 was
your pick), and we may have not get each other thoughts correctly I'm
afraid. But still, we can not hide the facts. The fact is you have
picked a player that by the cup rules was obliged to pause round 5. As
the old law says: ignorance of the law does not excuse no one. And I'm
afraid you can not deny that you clearly broke the rule. We can not let
it by, because it might be seen as a complaint of the team which lost
the game. If no one would obey the rules, we would have even bigger mess
over here.Every clan should have in mind which players can, and which players
can not play. It is not about 'we could have said that he joined months
ago and therefore can play', it is about keeping to the rules and being
fair when it concern others. It is terrible some people just forgot that
there is also a human on the other side of the screen (it is not
pointed on you, it is a general view of how it is), treat others like
you would like to be treated.We were once put in this kind of situation,
when three years ago we have 'lost' third place in TDML because the
other clan were not obeying all the rules, but those which fit them. But
I agree, we as the human beings are capable of making an error, the
difference is to admit that the error was made and try to fix it.We will not 'press any charges' against you, the game alone has been
played by any means fair, not concerning the issue we did not know
about back then. I only wish that you would admit that you have made an error, show us some good will and keep in mind that we are also human beings with feelings.I'm sure that most of thinks its not a big deal which does not do any
hard, but I do hope you will remember this as a lesson learned.If you have any questions or doubts let me know, and we will try to solve this the civilized way.
GG
there you go.
http://www.speedyshare.com/files/26961685/demos.rar
In my opinion leaders should pay attention if their player is not allowed to play in a game. Also trial period = not full membership so he isn't a clan member at all. Now, all remains in asp hands, and there should be also new rule added. Leaders take responsibility for their members and should see before cw if their members are allowed to play, otherwise WO for that team.
In my opinion leaders should pay attention if their player is not allowed to play in a game. Also trial period = not full membership so he isn't a clan member at all. Now, all remains in asp hands, and there should be also new rule added. Leaders take responsibility for their members and should see before cw if their members are allowed to play, otherwise WO for that team.
f1