Do you think it is usefull to have a Council on E+ , composed by the experienced players, that should take care of issues like cheating?

69 replies [Last post]
DARK
DARKLORD's picture
Offline
Joined: Jan 2005
Posts:
Do you think it is usefull to have a Council on E+ , composed by

well the council system sounds good to me, not only cause i was nominated but because its fair, 8 admin players (or more) fom various clans putting evidence together and discussing a reasonable punishment, we could also have a jury where we poll the evidence or select a few random members and ask their opinion too.

of course hq is right, we would need support of all or main server owners and maybe include them in the system.

but this isnt a time for rebelious freedom!! shouts or i hate government shouts, infact no one here really hates it, or they would probably have fallen ill and had no hospital to cure them otherwise, corruption of governments is what people hate, but i think if this community stood up and had a council it would be a big fu to cheaers and assholes and i think if even the slightest bit of corruption crept in it would be solved, remember corruption starts at one powerful mans mind, not 8 men discussing one person.

overall i think this is at least worth a test, if it is just a game then why whine that this is a bad idea and instead let it run a while and see if it improves our great community?

-----------------------------------------------------------------------

{D*R*T} FAITH
Faith's picture
Offline
Joined: Dec 2004
Posts:
Do you think it is usefull to have a Council on E+ , composed by
DARK wrote:

overall i think this is at least worth a test, if it is just a game then why whine that this is a bad idea and instead let it run a while and see if it improves our great community?

i said in other topic IMO its useless :} if u realy wanna put some work into improving this community, and making it bigger, --> take it to clanbase :} or focus on making some leagues,cups, ect. Big grin

btw. do u realy think some1 will agree to be banned coz "the council" said he cheated?.. it will resort even more flames, also council power can be abused!

the one and only way to dettect cheats is to enable pb [which detects cheats, better and better in newest relases] on every CW, cup, league, ect.. on public servers pb can be down, since those serves have many admins,[refeeres soon] which can be alerted when there is such need Smug ,and ban "cheating" mofo, coz its their server and they have right to IT!

ghost
Offline
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts:
Do you think it is usefull to have a Council on E+ , composed by
W L C wrote:

btw. do u realy think some1 will agree to be banned coz "the council" said he cheated?.. it will resort even more flames, also council power can be abused!

how?

judgment>verdict>ban by servers owners, 95% servers of comunity

do u rely do think u r making fair judgment couse u r server owner?

u wrote that some cheats can be detect only by pb (or eliminate by pure) yeap u r right, tell me then why im seeing players baning couse of walhacking? this is huge bulshit

tell me one thing more, why well know cheater still are on this forum and what is a reason that they are able to play on some servers ?

"C4-KICKZ"
KickZ's picture
Offline
Joined: Mar 2005
Posts:
Do you think it is usefull to have a Council on E+ , composed by
ghost wrote:

W L C wrote:

tell me one thing more, why well know cheater still are on this forum and what is a reason that they are able to play on some servers ?

True!...just tell me what i can do about it...Gunner was on r0 again today...Blizzarz/Gollem and more are still around...

what can we do?

...can you put PB on a website??? Big grin

<drt_nihil> we about wolf and wolf is here

(@enha) damn you, people are dancing, instead of work
(@drt_foksie) she mutated

un(player)
Unplayer's picture
Offline
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts:
Do you think it is usefull to have a Council on E+ , composed by

Gunner aparently keeps comming back ...he is just too thickheaded
to understand that we dont want him here and that he is gonna get blocked everytime.
We dont want to exclude all ip-addresses from forum...so whenever he pops up here it's because he found a new proxy or got a new isp or used an internet cafe or whatever.

But he will be blocked on every obvious attempt.

(HK) GoddaM
goddam's picture
Offline
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts:
Do you think it is usefull to have a Council on E+ , composed by
EVOL.WAX wrote:

my glass is full ive never had half a glass in my life Happy problem is it has floating pieces of shit called cheaters in it..and it sort of ruins the taste

and its not the lame ass noobs who come along with bad language and aimbots that is the concern. its the scum just under the surface that now and again get caught, the regular players who cheat that’s the true destructive problem

though as you dont care about such stuff goddam i presume you wount see this Winking

where did i say i dont care..? i care wholeheartedly - i dont care for talk that leads down the same path as the last conversation - my suggestion is to come up with some fresh ideas as you seem a man of resource and intelligence and have a true passion for the whole cheating subject - a real energy like this should not be wasted on covering the same ground, give me something new to work with and i am with you all the way. . . my server is yours for the trial of ANY idea you can come up with. . . just let me know.

EVOL.WAX
Forum moderator
WAX's picture
Offline
Joined: Jun 2004
Posts:
Do you think it is usefull to have a Council on E+ , composed by

The judges council IS a fresh idea.....its got a god damn (not intentional Winking) awful name, but the idea is on the right track.

....I see little point in carrying on this sidebar debate with you, its not leading anywhere

I have a point of view and I share it, if you feel the need to get more involved see casa, it’s his idea.

I believe I should type, Peace....
or something like that here.

(HK) GoddaM
goddam's picture
Offline
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts:
Do you think it is usefull to have a Council on E+ , composed by
EVOL.WAX wrote:

The judges council IS a fresh idea.....its got a god damn (not intentional Winking) awful name, but the idea is on the right track.

....I see little point in carrying on this sidebar debate with you, its not leading anywhere

I have a point of view and I share it, if you feel the need to get more involved see casa, it’s his idea.

I believe I should type, Peace....
or something like that here.

you are right wax, lets not carry on with a conversation that leads us both nowhere.

{D*R*T} FAITH
Faith's picture
Offline
Joined: Dec 2004
Posts:
Do you think it is usefull to have a Council on E+ , composed by
ghost wrote:

W L C wrote:
btw. do u realy think some1 will agree to be banned coz "the council" said he cheated?.. it will resort even more flames, also council power can be abused!

how?

judgment>verdict>ban by servers owners, 95% servers of comunity

do u rely do think u r making fair judgment couse u r server owner?

u wrote that some cheats can be detect only by pb (or eliminate by pure) yeap u r right, tell me then why im seeing players baning couse of walhacking? this is huge bulshit

tell me one thing more, why well know cheater still are on this forum and what is a reason that they are able to play on some servers ?

huh Big grin

holy,gunner ect - judgment>verdict>ban
he was judged>There were proofs he cheated>there was verdict>he was banned,

the only couse hes still playing is that he changes ISP, or has dynIP, and even forming judges council cant do anything bout it [well maybe> visit him with baseballl bat Tongue ]

I think my judgements [as server owner] are fair, coz they are always followed by proofs! Big grin
-if mofo cheated i got pb screenshot
-if mofo flamed, wasnt nice to ppl i got server log
-easy, if mofo didnt follow server rules, hes banned

bout that wallhack acussations - i SAID enable PB and thats the best judge, for me opinion like "omg, u cheat" not followed by proofs are just newb excusses, coz some1 is playing better

and as for power abuse:

when there is power, abuse will be for sure Smug

btw. do u all wanna this mod to get more and more ppl playing here? so why do we make ideas that are so "funny", plz tell me if im wrong, is there some kind of JUDGES COUNCIL on OSP,CPMA,RA3,XBattle?

now when people hear ExcessivePlus MOD name they laugh, [spamming weapons, nooby movment, ect] do we realy wanna give em' another thing to laugh from?

Lets focus on improving what we got now, coz imo its good system, and if we want to take E+ GAMING to next LEVEL > take it to CB

btw. not enough ppl voted, Big grin half of e+ players even dont visit this forum, u wanna take such IMPORTANT steps wihtout their knowlege Big grin

My conclusion is: like parasite said in few posts ago its just a game, dont spoil the fun Big grin its just a simple FPS Big grin leave it as it IS :}

cheers faith :}

*SUPREME*)NWC("
merauder's picture
Offline
Joined: Jan 2005
Posts:
Do you think it is usefull to have a Council on E+ , composed by

well if you used PB you could just ban his GUID... but you don't. so keep trying to ban his IP... and keep wasting your time.

Laughing Laughing Laughing Laughing Laughing Laughing Laughing

vote /sv_punkbuster 1