Do you think it is usefull to have a Council on E+ , composed by the experienced players, that should take care of issues like cheating?

69 replies [Last post]
ghost
Offline
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts:
Do you think it is usefull to have a Council on E+ , composed by
W L C wrote:


holy,gunner ect - judgment>verdict>ban
he was judged>There were proofs he cheated>there was verdict>he was banned,

he was baned on r0 servers but not on the rest, u make the verdict as the owner of r0 servers but almoust nobody folow u form couple of weeks

W L C wrote:


I think my judgements [as server owner] are fair, coz they are always followed by proofs! Big grin
-if mofo cheated i got pb screenshot
-if mofo flamed, wasnt nice to ppl i got server log
-easy, if mofo didnt follow server rules, hes banned

in obvious things no judgmet are needet, just a smart log put incase somebody will come to forum to bitching about, u r only one person who will make decysion, and what decysion u will make in case, xeno, ozzy

in that cases verdict of council will help to kep order

some ppl teling that giving to much power to not to meny ppl "council" around 10 ppl can make disasters, well compare it to sytuation now on what only one person make decysion....

W L C wrote:


bout that wallhack acussations - i SAID enable PB and thats the best judge, for me opinion like "omg, u cheat" not followed by proofs are just newb excusses, coz some1 is playing better

ehem moust walhacks are pk3 files, so enabling pb will not detect them

W L C wrote:


and as for power abuse:
when there is power, abuse will be for sure Smug

one person can make mistake, or use rcon to personal purposes, but if that are madet by 10 ppl with the same verdict can we sill talk about mistake ?

W L C wrote:


btw. do u all wanna this mod to get more and more ppl playing here? so why do we make ideas that are so "funny", plz tell me if im wrong, is there some kind of JUDGES COUNCIL on OSP,CPMA,RA3,XBattle?

yeap! that is a very good point they have systems MBL or stm like that, on each mod u pointed here, its a group of ppl that updating pb config and ban list for all servers owners

W L C wrote:


now when people hear ExcessivePlus MOD name they laugh, [spamming weapons, nooby movment, ect] do we realy wanna give em' another thing to laugh from?

hmmm go to iux and ask somebody what he think about lamers from ko, u can be suprised about the answer, and suprised couse some players forom iux moust powerful clans come here to play

W L C wrote:


Lets focus on improving what we got now, coz imo its good system, and if we want to take E+ GAMING to next LEVEL > take it to CB

we are trying to do this atm, "improving what we got"

W L C wrote:


My conclusion is: like parasite said in few posts ago its just a game, dont spoil the fun Big grin its just a simple FPS Big grin leave it as it IS :}

it mosut wrong statemet im read, if i will ban u for my fun or i run aimbot and pown u in league u will still be enjoing this game and have fun here?

im defenitly will have fun, and u not, but who cares it is only a game and we playing for fun....

idea of council is to kep more fun here, withnout flames, withnot wrong verdicts and angry ppl

nihil
nihil's picture
Offline
Joined: Dec 2004
Posts:
Do you think it is usefull to have a Council on E+ , composed by

now we should make council which will decide if to setup 'judges council'

this is just wasting of time more than playing itself
council.. what about hk holy case? we were council of 100 people telling them what to do, did they listen? and now same people got supreme idea how to improve community *gg*

anymore complicating of this community in this way leads to ass
if you like it lets do it

ghost
Offline
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts:
Do you think it is usefull to have a Council on E+ , composed by

idea of concil fails, but im wona expres my self, having MBL its good idea, and we need to do stm with wrong acusstion, warenman's topic working good, but im do think he has to meny pages couse of flames and we should atles have balck list "MBL" master ban list topic that will have poofs withnout eny dyscusions and it will be loock

and about concil, its look like u r watching at it form wrong side nihil, it not a group ppl to decide for u, its a group ppl that will make order if somebody will do not agree with yors decysion as a server admin

nihil
nihil's picture
Offline
Joined: Dec 2004
Posts:
Do you think it is usefull to have a Council on E+ , composed by
ghost wrote:

idea of concil fails, but im wona expres my self, having MBL its good idea, and we need to do stm with wrong acusstion, warenman's topic working good, but im do think he has to meny pages couse of flames and we should atles have balck list "MBL" master ban list topic that will have poofs withnout eny dyscusions and it will be loock

some regular pure blacklist is fine idea (or improved thingie like valid master ban list easily downloadable for any admin)

{D*R*T} FAITH
Faith's picture
Offline
Joined: Dec 2004
Posts:
Do you think it is usefull to have a Council on E+ , composed by
EVOL.WAX wrote:

The judges council IS a fresh idea.....its got a god damn (not intentional Winking) awful name, but the idea is on the right track.

....I see little point in carrying on this sidebar debate with you, its not leading anywhere

I have a point of view and I share it, if you feel the need to get more involved see casa, it’s his idea.

I believe I should type, Peace....
or something like that here.

well i gues ill stick to this rule that WAX wrote above, and i wont discuss it with ya, coz it has no sense,i just expressed my oppinon bout it :} , u wanna make it more complicated, do it, but i wont agree to be guided/forced to do sth just coz of council said so...

btw. banning guids would do good if q3 werent so old, now finding new cdkey is so easy that baning guids isnt effective Big grin

btw. whats next? e+ pressident?

cheers Big grin

Warren G
FELiX's picture
Offline
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts:
Do you think it is usefull to have a Council on E+ , composed by

I aggre with mbl

ghost
Offline
Joined: Jan 2004
Posts:
Do you think it is usefull to have a Council on E+ , composed by
W L C wrote:

but i wont agree to be guided/forced to do sth just coz of council said so...

:king:

yea that the point, u will not take cround of, did i worte stm about it long time ago ? Winking

W L C wrote:


btw. whats next? e+ pressident?

typing that caind of words, u can suspect similar answer

parasight [E+]
parasight's picture
Offline
Joined: Sep 2004
Posts:
Do you think it is usefull to have a Council on E+ , composed by

A simple MBL is a much more sensible solution than the whole jury idea. I could go with this.

nihil
nihil's picture
Offline
Joined: Dec 2004
Posts:
Do you think it is usefull to have a Council on E+ , composed by

mbl idea was here few times what i remember
but it crashed everytime because there were no people with time/mood for collecting/processing of data

(HK) GoddaM
goddam's picture
Offline
Joined: Aug 2004
Posts:
Do you think it is usefull to have a Council on E+ , composed by
nihil wrote:

ghost wrote:
idea of concil fails, but im wona expres my self, having MBL its good idea, and we need to do stm with wrong acusstion, warenman's topic working good, but im do think he has to meny pages couse of flames and we should atles have balck list "MBL" master ban list topic that will have poofs withnout eny dyscusions and it will be loock

some regular pure blacklist is fine idea (or improved thingie like valid master ban list easily downloadable for any admin)

http://www.hellknights.com/?page=cheaters

try here - posted topic about it ages ago - generator made by oldvamp.
has password to stop fools messing with it so selected admin from different servers can share their banstxt and new scum can be added all the time - anyone can generate and use the text on their server - useful huh! - perhaps this one can be utilised or a new one created and added to this forum..?