that's not a league, again, i'm not for limiting something. Clan choose themself how much they wanna play against who etc. Sure that means it's not perfect but that's not what we wanna do. If you guys think enough clans will be interested to do a league each year with rounds, schedulde matchs and more rules. Well let's see if someone wanna care this

also i will remeber one of the matters mentioned before

good clan rank must show actual best clan, that means presence not the past, so swe in the past was the best clan, indeed, but are they still the best? if so they must prove it by playing at least few cws, thats all, its fair in my eyes

create the rules etc and let us decide

wrote:

oh man i can't understand perfectly the boxing rate system you proposed for us. Do we really need something so complicated to rank our wars ?
...

man, this system can perfectly show clan's skill

read better and try understand it also better BoxRec Ratings Description

a small adition to bodz system.

all points earned are 10 times as much. the points earned are then multiplied by the win ration of the clan. and in case of loosing points, its multiplied by the reverse of the win ratio of the winning team.

so:

clans with same points or ( < or = 60 points difference) :

-winner 30 points, looser - 10

clans with more than 60 points difference :

- if logical win (better ranked clan win other clan) :winner 20 points looser -10
- if not logical win (other clan win better ranked clan :winner 40 points looser - 20

clans with more or = 120 points difference :

- if logical win : winner 10 looser 0
- if not logical win : winner 50 looser - 30

so lets take that by example.

lets say swe is 8th on list with very little points. they play ko wich are first and lead them by more than 120 points. swe has a 100% win ration, ko has a 90% win ratio.

if ko wins = ko get 10 points (10*1), swe doesnt loose points
if swe wins = swe get 45 points (50*0.9), ko loose 0 points (-30*(1-1))

now lets take an example of a imaginary clan Z. they have only 20% win ratio and are more than 120 points behind KO

if ko wins = ko gets 2 points (10*0.2) Z loose 0 points (0*(1-0.9))
if Z wins = Z gets 45 points (50*0.9) ko looses 24 points (-30*(1-0.2))

obviously being first to prove a clan can be beaten earns extra respect (and points) while destroying a clan everyone wrecks earn you little respect (and points). and loosing by a clan everyone else defeats earns a lot of penalty.

what you think people?